The method was banned from the army field manual in 2006 and by. Army field manuals, war departmentdepartment of the army pamphlets. The army field manual department of the army september 2006. The pentagon is now changing the 1992 army field manual rules for interrogation of prisoners, with the intent to cover this administrations criminal violations of it. The bill that bush vetoed would have required the cia to follow the standards of the army field manual, which forbids interrogation using force, electric shocks, forced nudity or sexual acts or. It includes purpose of this chapter is to define the interrogation information on the various levels of. The following diary is not meant to trash barack obama. This manual applies to the active army, the army national guard army national. The library of congress through the federal research division provides customized research and analytical services on foreign and domestic topics to united states government and district of. Army bans inhumane treatment of detainees washington times.
The pentagon has issued a new interrogation manual on how to deal with detainees. I got it to lend some reality to scenes in a story i was writing, but will have only marginal value. The measure would also require that the army field manual be updated every three years so that it is consistent with us law and reflects current evidencebased best practices for interrogation designed to elicit reliable and voluntary statements that do not involve the use or threat of force. They contain detailed information and howtos for procedures important to soldiers serving in the field. The other 18 are various forms of psychological interrogation.
T he united states army field manual afm on interrogation pdf has been sold to the american public and the world as a replacement for the brutal torture tactics used by the cia and the. The army field manuals list contains 19 techniques. Mar 12, 2008 the bill that bush vetoed would have required the cia to follow the standards of the army field manual, which forbids interrogation using force, electric shocks, forced nudity or sexual acts or. Cheney showcases new detainee gimp suit torture apparel. The administration pledged questioning would be controlled by the army field manual, with strict rules on tactics, and said the white house would keep. Bush vetoes bill banning harsh interrogation the hour. Appendix m authorizes what it calls separation, which involves physically separating. Army field manual how is army field manual abbreviated. As a petroleum lab specialist in the 2nd infantry and 101st airborne division, he was part of a team that tested fuel for air force one while deployed to kosovo in 2001. Pentagon set to drop geneva convention the sydney morning. Feb 20, 2008 gop hopeful says bush should veto bill barring harsh interrogation methods. This manual presents the fundamentals, procedures, and techniques for instrument flying and air navigation.
Black site prisons could be reinstated under president trump. This manual applies to the active army, the army national guardarmy national. The army field manual in 2006 banned using methods such as waterboarding or sensory deprivation on uncooperative prisoners. The military police consists of personnel authorized to a commander to assist him in the enforcement of laws, regulations, and orders, and for other purposes as. Pdf an empirical evaluation of intelligencegathering. Fm2223 us army field manual on interrogation as of 200609. Unless i enlarge my plot to include the impact of the wrong manual, of course. Aug 25, 2009 washington the obama administration is assigning a veteran prosecutor to begin a criminal probe of cia questioning of terror suspects during the bush. Wyden supports justice department probe of cia interrogation. Under the executive order, all government agencies are required to follow the army field manual on interrogation. The army field manual, which governs all military interrogations, lists approved maximization methods such as emotional fearup and emotionalpride and egodown.
In short, techniques that broke highranking alqaeda members like khalid sheikh mohammed and abu. Aug 24, 2009 cia interrogations spur criminal inquiry. Military human intelligence operations and interrogation field manual, fm 222. Following the ambiguous interpretations of what constitutes torture and illtreatment detailed in section a, the following interrogation techniques, which clearly went beyond earlier practice as contained in army field manual fm 3452, were approved by the secretary of defense on 2 december 2002. It provides an authoritative guide for leaders and soldiers, while allowing freedom to adapt to circumstances. Jan 26, 2017 the other ordered the cia to shut any detention facility it operated and prohibited the u. Although this report will discuss interrogation tactics that have been roundly. The army field manual does allow interrogation methods such as stress positions and sleep. The us army field manual on interrogation, sometimes known by the military nomenclature fm 3452, is a 177page manual describing to military interrogators. Washingtonvice president dick cheney has confirmed that u. Mar 09, 2008 during conference proceedings, conferees voted by a narrow margin to include a provision that would apply the army field manual to the interrogation activities of the central intelligence agency.
Bush keeps his word, vetoes ban of waterboarding news the. In short, techniques that broke highranking alqaeda members like khalid sheikh mohammed and abu zubaydah are now off the table indefinitely. Army releases new interrogation manual article the. It 0606 us army interrogation operations internet archive. United states army field manuals are published by the united states armys army publishing directorate. This question tracked interrogation approaches described in the army human intelligence collector operations field manual 25. The us army field manual on interrogation, sometimes known by the military nomenclature fm 3452, is a 177page manual describing to military interrogators how to conduct effective interrogations while conforming with us and international law. Mccains first amendment would have established the army field manual as the standard for interrogation of all detainees held in the department of defense dod. The dark side of interrogation center for law, brain and. Jun 05, 2006 pentagons interrogation manual dodges geneva ban. As of 27 july 2007, some 542 field manuals were in use. Dec 10, 2014 franks says mccain wrong on waterboarding as torture. Military human intelligence operations and interrogation.
Field manual 3452 headquarters department of the anny. In new manual, army limits tactics in interrogation the. On his second day as president, barack obama ordered the agency to use the army field manual as its interrogation playbook. Two senior officials said there will not be a classified section in the longawaited revision of the army field manual. Mar 11, 2008 the vetoed legislation would have limited the cia to using only the 19 interrogation methods approved in the army field manual. In 2015, congress passed legislation which limits the government interrogation techniques to those prescribed in the army field manual, thereby banning waterboarding and other coercive methods.
Contrary to obamas promises, the us military still. Jan 25, 2017 the other ordered the cia to shut any detention facility it operated and prohibited the u. Pentagons interrogation manual dodges geneva ban world. In a welcome return to those principles and values, the senate, brushing aside the threat of a bush veto, voted 90 to 9 to outlaw the cruel, degrading and inhuman treatment of any prisoner in u. Trump says torture works, but wont authorize new policy.
On the second day of his presidency, barack obama wanted to send a clear message. As has been previously reported by the daily caller, the mccainfeinstein amendment that passed in june, and was signed into law the day before thanksgiving limits all interrogators to using only those techniques described in the army field manual. Hayden was critical, at the same time, of recent public commentary that implied only two outcomes are possible a blanket application of the army field manual or the legalization of torture. Pentagon changes army field manual governing interrogation. Basic field manual military police this manual supersedes basic field manual, volume ix, december 31, 1937. There are currently 468 field manuals available and many more are on their way. That guidebook bans the use of waterboarding, a technique that.
Former cia agents, politicos condemn trumps torture remarks. However, the army field manual on human intelligence collector operations, which binds both military and cia interrogators, permits methods of interrogation that are recognized under international. They are usually available to the public at low cost or free electronically. An executive order signed by obama now requires that interrogations of anyone in u. Its worth a read just to realize how important assumptions can be in determining interrogation methods. A littleknown appendix to the army field manual, the government rulebook for interrogations that bans the harsh practices used after the sept. Nov 30, 2015 as has been previously reported by the daily caller, the mccainfeinstein amendment that passed in june, and was signed into law the day before thanksgiving limits all interrogators to using only those techniques described in the army field manual. Mar 17, 2020 jones spent eight years in the army, from 1998 to 2007.
The army field manual comes nowhere near the legal line of what you can do in an interrogation and therefore ties the hands of cia interrogators unnecessarily. Bbc news americas the obama approach to interrogation. Bush said the cia must retain use of specialised interrogation. Pentagon changes army field manual governing interrogation of prisoners this nest of american traitors is in deep, deep trouble. Bush veto stands on bill prohibiting waterboarding twin cities. The united states army field manual on interrogation instructs military interrogators how to conduct effective interrogations while conforming with u. At the operational level, ipb identifies the enemys tions. President obamas decision to ban enhanced interrogation techniques in favor of the army field manual guideline got me thinking about just what types of information extraction strategies. Bush said he vetoed the measure because it is important for the cia to have a separate and classified interrogation program. Army releases electronic warfare field manual article. Jan 22, 2009 however, he cautioned obama not to hold the agency to the army field manual, saying that it was designed for battlefield interrogations, not for intelligence officers. Cheney confirms that detainees were subjected to water. Armys field manual to ciathe army field manual on inter rogations, than it. The revamped manual, titled human intelligence collector operations, is part of a wideranging overhaul of interrogation and detention policies and operations undertaken by.
United states army field manuals are published by the united states army s army publishing directorate. The cincinnati post torture is a crime, not a policy. National defense authorization act shows terrorists our. During conference proceedings, conferees voted by a narrow margin to include a provision that would apply the army field manual to the interrogation activities of the central intelligence agency. The manual, originally written for cold war prisoners but updated in 2006, states that no detainee, regardless of nationality or physical location, shall be subject to cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment or. Congress to clash with bush over torture technique world news. Mar 09, 2008 bush keeps his word, vetoes ban of waterboarding. The most recent revision was renamed field manual fm 222. Top ten army field manual interrogation guidelines white. Dec, 2007 the legislation approved by the house today would require that all u. It is based on lessons learned from previous counterinsurgencies and contemporary operations. Oct 16, 2017 he warns that, despite obamas efforts to reform the practice of interrogation, abuses are still possible through the army field manual, a document meant to rein in abuses.
Jan 26, 2017 congress passed the national defense authorization act in 2015, which reaffirmed a prohibition on torture and required u. Section 820 of this field manual 26 lists specific approaches that military interrogators should use when attempting to induce cooperation in an interrogation subject. Army and marine corps counterinsurgency field manual 2 a counterinsurgency campaign is, as described in this manual, a mix of offensive, defensive, and stability. Regulation 2536, the doctrine in this field manual is not policy in and of itself, but is a body of thought on how army forces operate. Huckabee oppose the army field manual standard for interrogations. All manuals are available to military personnel and civilians alike. A revamped army field manual for intelligence collection sets out 19 interrogation techniques for detainees that are permitted and the eight that are banned. Sep 07, 2006 a revamped army field manual for intelligence collection sets out 19 interrogation techniques for detainees that are permitted and the eight that are banned. Although the army field manual contains a number of express and. Jun 06, 2006 the pentagon has been redrawing policies on prisoners and interrogation for more than a year, and intends to issue a new army field manual, which, with accompanying directives, represents core. Military field manuals mfm allows you to quickly and easily find and download free military manuals on a wide variety of subjects. The field manual was sometimes known by the code fm 3452. The manual gives instructions on a range of issues, such as the structure, planning and management of human intelligence operations, the debriefing of soldiers, and the analysis of known relationships and map data.
But rear admiral guter argues that it cant be the policy of the us to have more than one interrogation regime. Army field manual is sufficient a bill on interrogation techniques was passed on february, 2008 in the us senate, in a 51 to 45 vote, limiting the number of techniques allowed to only those interrogation techniques explicitly authorized by the 2006 army field manual. Delayed more than a year amid criticism of the defense departments treatment of prisoners, the new army field manual was released wednesday, revising one from 1992 it. Contrary to obamas promises, the us military still permits. Washington the three executive orders that president barack obama signed on thursday to shut the guantanamo bay and cia prisons begin to untangle some of the legal, diplomatic and practical. Justice launches probe of cia news tuscaloosa news. Jan 25, 2014 t he united states army field manual afm on interrogation pdf has been sold to the american public and the world as a replacement for the brutal torture tactics used by the cia and the.
Congress has already limited the pentagon to the field manual, which. Controversial interrogation techniques used by the cia have been. Under a 2005 law, the armys new field manual becomes the pentagons guiding document for. Cia interrogations spur criminal inquiry daily news. Aug 24, 2009 the manual, last updated in september 2006, authorizes 19 interrogation methods used to question prisoners, including one allowing a detainee to be isolated from other inmates in some cases. We encountered a threat we were not prepared for and we. Counterinsurgency open pdf 14 mb this field manualmarine corps warfighting publication establishes doctrine fundamental principles for military operations in a counterinsurgency coin environment. I spent a good deal of time researching it, and i had a lot of discussion with a dod spokesman clarifying the issues. Democrats and human rights advocates criticized president bushs veto saturday of a bill that would have banned the cia from using simulated drowning and other coercive interrogation methods to. Torture is illegal, but theres the issue of appendix m. The manual, last updated in september 2006, authorizes 19 interrogation methods used to question prisoners, including one allowing a detainee to be isolated from other inmates in some cases. Obamas orders only the start of a detainee policy overhaul.
Army tactics field manual by department of the army. He was also a reservist, and mobilized to fort benning in 2006 as a supply sergeant for a basic training unit. Interrogations must follow army field manual along with the order to shut down the guantanamo detention camp, president obama put a stop to. Only one of which, separation, is an overtly physical tactic. President bush publicly acknowledges the programme for the first time.
588 1436 6 106 778 277 188 1231 1262 373 935 383 946 1555 1492 751 1483 906 134 1292 239 1100 1499 702 1271 1077 465 729 642 984 1422 1285 732 1124 276 1124 829 1076 96 1324 1425 472